Nurses’ Rights

The hospital I work in used to have posters hanging up, describing patients’ rights. The right to have their medical care explained to them, the right to refuse treatment, the right to be treated courteously, the right emergency care regardless of the circumstances.

These posters are no longer displayed, but the concept hasn’t gone away. The healthcare team I work with makes every effort to treat people fairly and humanely. If a person refuses a test or treatment, that’s fine. If someone wants to leave against medical advice, they are free to go.

Health care professionals actually have very few rights. What other profession is not allowed to drink water while they do computer work, or sip on coffee throughout the day? Or to work twelve hours without a break to eat? In what other profession is it part of the job to be cursed at, spit at and threatened?

And what if I’m a bedside nurse, and I very strongly disagree with the course of treatment? Where is my right to refuse? What about when it becomes my job to torture someone?

Charlie Guard, the English child whose parents wanted to fly him into the US for experimental treatment, because an unfortunate poster child for Republicans campaign against state sponsored healthcare. Out of all the garbage written about that, I read one good article. A nurse wrote about working in a PICU and watching patients suffer. Think of the nurses, she wrote, who know a patient is suffering and are forced to be part of that suffering, knowing the outcome.

We had this patient, George in our ICU a few years ago. George was 95 and he had cancer. He was never able to speak for himself, so his son spoke for him. George was with us for close to two months. In that time, he suffered unspeakably. Anyone with any medical experience knows that people with bony metastasis require a lot of pain medications. The patient’s son insisted, repeatedly, that we only medicate him with tylenol, because he didn’t want him given narcotics. (We gave them anyway, when the son wasn’t there.)  He insisted his father undergo radiation, wanted him to have chemo and if he wasn’t weaning from the vent, why couldn’t he get a trach?

He got the radiation. Chemo and a trach were out of the question. But according to our current healthcare structure, the patient has a right to autonomy, to make their own decisions. In lieu of the patient, the surrogate decision maker calls the shots. He or she is supposed to speak to what is in the patient’s best interest but too often, they are thinking of themselves. Or they’re irrational. Who bears the consequences of these decisions? The patient, the physicians and the nursing staff. Especially the nursing staff. The things we do to patients in the ICU are horrible, but they’re in the name of preserving life. When death is imminent no matter what, these needles and tubes become instruments of torture. When George’s heart stopped, we were required by law to do CPR, with the knowledge that we would only break his ribs.

I took care of George about two weeks into his stay, on a day when we trialed him off the ventilator. He lasted about twenty minutes. In those minutes, his eyes closed. His pulse and respiratory rate increased as his oxygen levels dropped, but he rested. He was 95 and terminally ill. We had to re-intubate him, of course, because his son was dictating his care and I believe it was the first time I’ve cried during an intubation.

Where are the nurse’s rights in that situation? Why am I forced to torture when I am in this profession to comfort and cure? Consider a patient with advanced parkinson’s getting chemo, or the patient who said she wanted to be left in peace, but since she cannot speak for herself, now has a feeding tube. The 88 year old with no family that wants CPR but no breathing tube and so we code her until two physicians agree that we have tried long enough.  My fellow nurses and I become part of the conspiracy, a gang of brutes, preying on the helpless, with no choice but to comply, with the knowledge that we are causing pain, wasting resources and the end result is death. Beyond outright quitting, we have absolutely no choice in the matter. Unlike our patients, we don’t have the right to refuse.

4 thoughts on “Nurses’ Rights

  1. Completely agree. I had a number of ‘Georges’ in my ICU career. One of my patients, after looking around at what was going on in the ICU from her bed said, “They work you like dogs!” Yep. But, unfortunately very few people see this, let alone do anything about it.


  2. Totally agree with you. Nursing is one of the most difficult jobs in the world! I love it though….could never or would never be anything else. This is the stuff that matters…..helping people when they are down and out.


  3. I urge you to look at Hearts In Healthcare. They are a fabulous organisation. You are right- healthcare is a system gone mad, in your country and mine. And as nurses we are forces to be party to the inhumanity, or leave. I left, and am now passionate about changing the system from the inside out, by supporting the health care workers. I applaud your candour and courage. Thank you.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s